As a consequence of the Holocaust, Israel’s security is officially regarded as part of Germany’s “reason of state”. Yet the criteria for a responsible relationship between Germany and Israel are by no means self-evident or without logical or practical contradictions. One of the complications is the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. In order to better understand this complication, Gert Krell examines in Working Paper No. 26 "Shadows from the Past: The Nazi-Regime, the Holocaust, and Germany’s Relationship towards the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict" two familiar national narratives, one from each side, about possible connections between the Nazi era, the Holocaust, and this conflict.
Gert Krell also puts the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in a broader historical context. It turns out that the examined relationships are not as obvious as the familiar narratives describe them.
The origins of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict are older than the Nazi era and the Holocaust, and they also point to broader European responsibilities more generally, to Europe’s nationalism, anti-Semitism, colonialism and imperialism – with irresponsibilities towards both Jews and Arabs. In no way does such a comprehensive perspective affect Germany’s special historical responsibilities resulting from the Holocaust. But it puts the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in a more complete and also more honest framework, with consequences for Germany’s moral and political position.
Dr Gert Krell is professor emeritus for International Politics at Goethe-University Frankfurt/Main. At PRIF, he has been a research fellow from 1971-1977 and head of a research group from 1981-1995.
This PRIF Working Paper can be downloaded here.